How behavioral economics revises basic ideas of economic analysis: endowment effect, loss aversion, scarcity, self-control, experiments, and nudges. Note from March 2019.
In the previous edition of Academic Bridge, we presented an article with six basic ideas that we assumed are found in an economist's essential toolbox. Undoubtedly, the title was quite ambitious (why six and not seven? Why these concepts and not others?). Furthermore, it was likely open to objections from other schools of thought, or even from other approaches or branches of economics.
A quick example : in the media (and also in academia) greater importance is usually given to macroeconomic concepts, without much connection to microeconomic concepts, which are the ones that account for the decisions that people make.
But the problem isn't that simple either: there simply isn't a single microeconomics. Indeed, one of the alternative approaches that has been gaining ground through publications and empirical evidence is what has been called behavioral economics . This branch develops a body of more realistic explanations about the actual behavior of economic agents.
From the rational agent to behavioral economics
This contrasts with the mainstream view, which proposes the rational agent as the model. These are individuals who act based on calculations of optimal behavior, weighing the costs and benefits of each economic decision they make. In contrast, under behavioral assumptions, rationality loses ground in the decision-making process. It gives way to intuition, environmental influences, cognitive biases, endowments, the status quo, self-control, values, learning processes, and more.
What's interesting about this era is that the debate is open and constantly evolving, with arguments, counterarguments, and evidence being presented. Furthermore, microeconomic concepts, since they largely deal with the factors that influence our decision-making processes, tend to be more intuitive than macroeconomic phenomena.
1- For a sincere economist, everything has a cost... but our behavior tends to increase it
In the previous article, it was stated that “at the heart of economic analysis lies a decision.” What does this mean? It means that, given a specific context, a decision made by an agent necessarily involves comparing at least two alternatives. In other words, when one chooses to do “something,” one inevitably forgoes doing “something else.” Which one? The best alternative that is forgone when making a choice is called the opportunity cost.
The opportunity cost of reading this note may be taking a nap. Unless you're using reading to fall asleep, in which case the alternative would be something else: let the article get interesting (maybe).
The existence of endowment effects greatly complicates this calculation . In behavioral terms, an agent's valuation of an asset changes depending on whether or not they own it. If something is mine, it automatically has more value for me than it does in the market. To reiterate, the endowment effect adds a surplus of value to the asset an agent owns, which can no longer be valued by the price system. Given this asymmetry, the calculation of value is disrupted, as an opportunity cost cannot be imputed at market prices.
Marie Kondo and the endowment effect
It seems that Marie Kondo , the acclaimed tidying guru, has cleverly exploited the endowment effect. Experiments demonstrating this effect show that most people tend to hold onto what they already own. Donating, throwing away, or even selling something is perceived as a loss, unless there's a compelling reason to change.
In the case of Kondo's reality show , the reason for change is to achieve a more harmonious life. But Kondo's approach isn't about explaining concepts or judging whether a particular family has a disastrous home or not. On the contrary, it's about creating rituals and teaching through feelings.
A formula that seems more effective at dealing with endowment effects than the cold, calculating logic of the traditional approach. That calculating logic, moreover, will give you an obvious answer. If you prefer your house to be messy, tidy it up; subject to your time constraints. If not, chances are you've already found your own optimal level of clutter.
2- Losses are felt more than gains
A concept closely related to the previous one is the idea of loss aversion . It is one of the fundamental, and also foundational, concepts of behavioral economics. It shows that there is an asymmetry in how we value losses compared to gains. For example, to compensate for a loss of $100, one needs to gain $200. In other words, the utility of gaining $100 is much less than the disutility of losing $100.
The concept is fundamental for several reasons. The first is subtle. If what's at stake is profit or loss, what's implicitly being stated is that people react to changes (in the flow of money) rather than to absolute levels (of wealth). Let's think about a multi-millionaire soccer player, such as Lionel Messi.
A mere mortal like you or me might wonder what motivates someone with a fat bank account to keep working. After all, they have enough wealth to never have to work again, covering a high standard of living.
If there is a net worth of approximately €230 million, under the traditional economic analysis model an additional €100 thousand would not seem to provide greater utility. However, Messi continues playing because - again - what is taken into account is profit and not accumulated wealth.
The status quo bias
The other reason is more explicit. If agents are loss-averse, and this is compounded by the endowment effect, we are faced with status quo bias. If any change that doesn't offer a strong return is perceived as a loss, then agents end up being reluctant to change.
The status quo is taken as a point of reference, creating an impulse to be conservative. This is something that our popular wisdom has immortalized with the saying "better the devil you know than the devil you don't," and it acts even against our own interests.
3- I don't know what I want, but I feel like I want it now
It's a oft-repeated phrase that economics is the science of scarcity. Let's look at this example: for the moment, given the tendency to underestimate the environmental problem, a diamond is worth more than a thousand liters of water. Naturally, water is essential for human survival, while a diamond is not.
However, the diamond's high value stems from its relative scarcity . And as we mentioned in the first point, in a market economy, the valuation of a good is mediated by the price system: if something is expensive, it's because it's worth more.
An astute reader may rebuke us that many times the price is set by a few companies, which does not necessarily reflect their relative scarcity, but rather their market power.
In the previous article, we also discussed the difficulties this central concept presents for economics. But for the purposes of this note, we will focus on emphasizing that both the idea of scarcity and the problems of its application through the price system were objective in nature.
Subjective scarcity and attention capture
Behavioral economists don't dismiss this concept or its difficulties, but they also take into account the effects of subjective scarcity on people's decisions. What does this mean? Having less than what is perceived as necessary.
The key finding of these studies is that there is a common logic to scarcity. This logic works by capturing the attention of those who experience (or suffer from) it, when they focus their thoughts excessively on it. An interesting aspect of this concept is that the idea applies to everyone, regardless of their wealth.
Let's consider a doctor with a high income but little time for their personal life. The experience of scarcity won't be about resources, but rather about time to—let's say—dedicate to their family. Now, what are the implications of this " capture" ? A complete alteration of experience and a reduction in decision-making capacity. Someone who feels they have no time for anything focuses their thoughts on the time that is slipping away. What are the effects? Loss of insight, suppression of innovative thinking, and loss of self-control.
In this way, attention-grabbing works by focusing attention, but in such a way as to concentrate on a deficiency that a cost is paid by losing overall analytical capacity. The example we gave of a person with little time was a positive one. Let's now consider what happens with a person living in poverty.
The vicious cycle of poverty
If a lack of resources captures your attention, it nullifies your capacity for innovative thinking and the ability to create solutions to escape (or alleviate) that difficult situation. The loss of self-control prevents you from making the small savings necessary—for example, to replace a broken tool part with a new one, a sewing machine, or a bread oven—thus reinforcing the vicious cycle of poverty.
If subjective scarcity has a common structure that determines a person's field of decisions, blaming a poor person for their situation is a brutal conceptual error.
4- What is desirable in the short term may be bad for the future (and vice versa)
In the previous article, we mentioned that a good economist must consider how the effects of an action or measure are distributed over time . For example, in a very simplified scenario, let's consider a sudden monetary expansion that is not initially priced in by the market. This could lead to a brief period of prosperity in the short term. If that prosperity does not generate a genuine stimulus for increased production, it results in an inflationary spike in the medium term.
Thus, what is considered good in the present may have negative effects in the future. However, as the reader will have noticed, all expected effects are derived from a rational calculation.
Applying this framework to the time-based calculations made by economic agents, traditional economic thought asserts that they have a preference for the immediate. For example, $100 now is valued more highly than that same $100 in a year. This premise is significant, as it explains various behaviors.
One example is the behavior associated with prize payouts. In the US, lottery winnings can be paid in two ways: a lump sum or divided into 30 annual installments. The payout system exploits the principle of immediate preference, because when the winner chooses the lump sum, the amount received is comparatively less than the total they would receive from the sum of the 30 annual installments, with the corresponding adjustments over time.
Self-control problems
But do economic agents think and act according to these calculation parameters? Behavioral studies answer this question with a resounding no. This is due to the existence of self-control problems that go beyond the premise of a preference for the immediate. Behavioral economics asserts (and justifies) that economic agents are inconsistent over time in their decision-making.
To put it simply: even if they've created a plan, and even if they reap some benefits from following it, they struggle to stick to it. Consider paying a club or gym membership fee. They pay, they acknowledge that exercise is good for their health, they attend for the first few months, and then eventually stop. Obviously, not everyone adopts this attitude, but the lazier segment of society certainly does.
Even more serious is what happens when self-control problems are combined with capture due to scarcity. Think about what happens with the follow-up of prolonged medical treatment, when attention is captured by another issue. Under self-control and capture, treatments can be partially interrupted, or become poorly administered.
This new understanding of human behavior is more comprehensive and poses challenges to public policy design . It is no longer just about improving access problems (to rights, services, goods, medicines) but also about considering usage problems (effective exercise of rights, use of services under certain quality standards, goods that fulfill the function for which they were designed, medicines that are administered correctly).
5- Many discussions are resolved by measuring, but when it cannot be measured, experiments can be done.
Statistics and econometrics are the dominant tools of applied economics . This makes sense, because these tools allow us to understand the behavior of variables, not only descriptively (the dollar rose, the dollar fell) but also to quantify the relationships established between different variables within an economic model (if the issuance of pesos increases, and everything else remains constant, the dollar increases).
But it also makes sense from a contextual perspective. The technological changes of recent decades have created an exceptional volume of information for these types of studies. These studies no longer necessarily depend on statistical agencies or on securing funding to conduct their own surveys.
Currently, the vast majority of generated information is kept private. Furthermore, many platforms offer open access to their databases for analysis. This is the case with Twitter, which allows access to its database through its API interface.
But what happens when the relevant data for an economic proposition are not directly observable in a natural economic environment? In other words, what happens when the theory exists, but not the empirical counterpart that can be measured and then verified?
The place of experiments in economics
In this case, two things can be done. We can accept the deductions of the economic model as fact… or we can design an experiment . In our part of the world, this point still seems like a novelty. Until not too recently, a well-known introductory economics text stated: “Economists [unfortunately]… cannot carry out the controlled experiments of chemists or biologists… Like astronomers or meteorologists, they must generally be content to a great extent with observation.”
Fortunately, Vernon Smith created the induced value methodology , which earned him the 2002 Nobel Prize in Economics , "for establishing laboratory experiments as a tool in empirical economic analysis, particularly in the study of alternative market mechanisms." This methodology has enabled a series of developments. These have facilitated the search for empirical regularities, the dialogue between different theories, and the formulation of economic policy recommendations.
Fortunately, experimental design methodology has greatly facilitated the validation and development of concepts and theoretical frameworks from the field of behavioral economics. Perhaps one of the most popular experiments is the ultimatum game , which has applications in the field of perceived fairness, an aspect rarely addressed by neoclassical economics.
The ultimatum game
What is an ultimatum game? It requires two players. The first player is asked to divide a certain amount of money—let's say $100—with the other player by making a single, final proposal for how to divide it. The second player can then accept or reject the first player's proposal. If it's rejected, neither player gets anything. If it's accepted, the money is divided according to the first player's terms.
Given this situation, the prediction offered by rationalist theory consists of an offer of $99 by the first player and the acceptance of the remaining peso by the second.
Ultimately, $1 is better than nothing, and both players know it. The strategic calculation would then go something like this: If I know the other player knows that $1 is better than nothing, then I can keep $99 and offer them $1. I do this because I'm certain they'll accept, given that we're both rational.
However, this is not what happens in laboratory experiments. Ultimatum games have shown that people are willing to penalize low-value offers even at the risk of losing everything. Those playing the role of offerors assume this is the case. Therefore, they end up offering money splits in proportions like 60%-40%.
6- Incentives matter, and sometimes big impacts can be achieved with a little push
In the previous article we argued that incentives -in general- and monetary incentives -in particular- are an essential tool in the formulation and execution of economic initiatives, whether public or private.
An example of the first type is the Universal Child Allowance ( AUH ). This provides a monetary allowance based on the number of children, targeted at families in vulnerable populations. In return, families must ensure their children's vaccination records are up to date and that they attend school throughout the year.
For its part, an example from the private sector are compensation systems in which, as one moves up the hierarchy, amenities are added : company car, improvements in the social security coverage plan, home office , transfer possibilities, company shares, etc.
In general terms, what both examples assert is that people respond to monetary incentives in a predictable way, based (again) on a notion of calculation. From a behavioral perspective, and having already seen the concepts in the previous points, this is not necessarily the case.
Bounded rationality and decision architecture
Self-control problems, endowment effects, status quo bias, loss aversion, and scarcity capture are all variations of the broader concept of bounded rationality . If, under certain circumstances, our computational capacity is compromised, then the decision we make as an economic agent will hardly be close to optimal.
What can be done in public policy formulation under this scenario? Anticipate errors, and design policies considering the decision-making architecture of those who will be the beneficiaries.
What does this mean? It means that the organization of the context will be taken into account in order to propose options that encourage the best response with an improvement objective. It sounds strange, but it's actually something we're already used to.
For example, a programmer assumes that the user has virtually no computer skills. Therefore, when a program is installed on a computer, it offers either a default configuration or the option to modify these parameters to suit the user (which is generally not done). The same applies to cell phones. The options are there, but a pre-configured version is offered that is considered desirable.
Default options and nudges
The default options carry enormous weight and are intimately linked to the status quo effect discussed above. Under bounded rationality, most decisions are not made based on calculation, but rather by following the option presented. In other words, continuing with inertia, like someone crossing the street looking at what the person in front is doing instead of looking at the traffic light.
However, the fact that a decision can be influenced (and this is something advertising does to us constantly) raises serious ethical problems in public policymaking. A patient can be induced to take their medication by receiving text messages as reminders. But is this interference ethical? The justification rests on two points.
- The induced option is not the only one available and the decision-making capacity is not nullified.
- The understanding that in practically any circumstance there is no default option that is not neutral. If text messages were not sent when taking medications, knowing that there was a risk of interrupting treatment, would it be ethical?
A large-scale nudge: the Justina Law
Finally, when a public policy considers the decision-making architecture of its beneficiaries, it is said to be providing a nudge . It is a small push that modifies people's behavior in a predictable way without prohibiting any option.
The Justina Law , which came into effect on August 3, 2018, is perhaps the most significant change implemented in Argentina. It modifies the default organ donation option by reversing the terms. Now, everyone over 18 is considered an organ donor unless they voluntarily opt out. As a result, according to INCUCAI (National Central Institute for Organ Donation and Transplantation), the first two months of the year saw a 35% year-on-year increase in organ donations.
Open access, for use and citation
The report is available freely and without charge, under a Creative Commons license (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0):
- 📄 Full report (PDF): Download the report
- 🗄️ UNR Hypermedia Repository (RepHip): https://hdl.handle.net/2133/17523
- 📚 More reports from the Observatory: Index of Reports
6 ideas para entender cómo piensa un economista conductual. Informes del Observatorio UNR N.º 46 — Serie Puente Académico N.º 15, marzo de 2019. ISSN 2683-9067 / 2683-9091. Autor: Germán A. Tessmer.




